Cancellation of Removal: Do You Qualify?
Cancellation of removal is a defense you raise in immigration court, not an application you file with USCIS. If an immigration judge grants it, the removal case ends and, for a person without a green card, permanent residence follows. There are two routes. A person without a green card needs ten years of continuous physical presence, good moral character, no disqualifying conviction, and proof that removal would cause exceptional and extremely unusual hardship to a spouse, parent or child who is a U.S. citizen or permanent resident. A permanent resident needs five years as a resident, seven years of continuous residence after a lawful admission, and no aggravated felony conviction.
This page explains each requirement, the stop-time rule that ends the clock when a notice to appear is served, the yearly cap, how the application is filed and heard in the Newark and Elizabeth courts, and what the hardship standard really asks.
Call (973) 735-2716 to talk through your situation with Harry Asatrian.
Two Routes, One Statute
Section 240A of the Immigration and Nationality Act gives an immigration judge the power to cancel the removal of two kinds of people. Section 240A(a) covers lawful permanent residents. Section 240A(b)(1) covers people who are not permanent residents, and when the judge grants it the judge also adjusts the person's status to permanent resident. A third, narrower route in section 240A(b)(2) covers a spouse, a child, or the parent of an abused child, battered or subjected to extreme cruelty by a citizen or resident, with three years of presence, good moral character and extreme hardship to the applicant, a child or a parent. Each route is discretionary: meeting the requirements makes you eligible, and the judge then decides whether you deserve the relief on the whole record.
The relief exists only inside removal proceedings. You cannot apply for it before the government charges you, and a person who wants to raise it must be in proceedings before an immigration judge. That is why a notice to appear, frightening as it is, opens the door to cancellation for someone who has lived here for many years with a citizen or resident family: it is the first moment the application can be made.
Cancellation for People Without a Green Card
Under section 240A(b)(1) the judge may cancel removal and adjust the status of a person who proves four things.
Ten years of continuous physical presence
You must have been physically present in the United States for a continuous period of not less than ten years immediately before the date of the application. The statute defines a break: a single absence of more than 90 days, or absences adding up to more than 180 days, ends the continuity. Shorter trips do not. The ten years are counted back from the application, but the clock stops earlier under the stop-time rule explained below.
Good moral character for those ten years
You must have been a person of good moral character during the ten-year period. The Act lists conduct that bars a finding of good moral character, including certain convictions, false testimony to obtain an immigration benefit, and confinement as the result of a conviction for an aggregate of 180 days or more; beyond the list, the judge looks at the whole record of the period.
No disqualifying conviction
You must not have been convicted of an offense under section 212(a)(2), 237(a)(2) or 237(a)(3) of the Act, which together cover crimes involving moral turpitude, controlled substance offenses, aggravated felonies, firearms offenses, domestic violence offenses and document fraud, among others. Whether a particular conviction falls within those sections is a legal question that often decides the case, and it is examined before anything else.
Exceptional and extremely unusual hardship
You must establish that removal would result in exceptional and extremely unusual hardship to your spouse, parent or child who is a citizen of the United States or a lawful permanent resident. Hardship to you does not count under this route. The Board of Immigration Appeals has read the words to require hardship "substantially beyond" what ordinarily follows from a family member's removal: in Matter of Monreal-Aguinaga the Board said the standard is a high one, though it does not require that the hardship be unconscionable, and that the judge weighs the ages, health and circumstances of the qualifying relatives, with the conditions in the country of removal counting only as they affect those relatives and generally not enough on their own. In Matter of Recinas the Board found the standard met for a single mother of six children, four of them citizens, with no immediate family remaining in Mexico, limited financial resources, and real difficulty establishing comparable economic stability there.
The hardship case is where most of the work lies. A child's medical condition that could not be treated abroad, a child with compelling special needs in school, an elderly parent solely dependent on the applicant, the loss of a family's only income, and the conditions a citizen child would face in the country of removal are the kinds of facts the decisions turn on, documented through medical, school, financial and country records and the testimony of the family.
Cancellation for Permanent Residents
Under section 240A(a) the judge may cancel the removal of a lawful permanent resident who has been a permanent resident for not less than five years, has resided in the United States continuously for seven years after having been admitted in any status, and has not been convicted of an aggravated felony. There is no hardship requirement and no limit on the number of grants, but the relief is discretionary, and the judge weighs the conviction that brought the person to court, the person's rehabilitation, family ties, work history and length of residence, and the equities against the adverse factors, as the Board's decisions direct.
Two definitions matter. "Admitted in any status" means the seven years can begin with a lawful entry in any status, such as on a visa, not only from the date the green card was granted; a parole is not an admission. And "aggravated felony" is a term of art defined in section 101(a)(43) of the Act that covers many state offenses, some of them misdemeanors under state law; whether a conviction is an aggravated felony is decided by comparing the elements of the offense with the federal definition, and in some categories by the sentence imposed, not by the state's label for it.
In removal proceedings and not sure what relief is open? Call (973) 735-2716. Tell us the court, the next hearing date and when you came to the United States. We will say which forms of relief the facts support and what the record needs.
Speak With an AttorneyThe Stop-Time Rule and the Yearly Cap
Section 240A(d)(1) ends the period of continuous residence or physical presence on the earlier of two events: when the person is served a notice to appear under section 239(a), or when the person commits an offense under section 212(a)(2) that makes them inadmissible or removable. The notice to appear, not the hearing, stops the clock, so a person served in the ninth year of presence does not reach ten years by waiting; the notice rule does not apply to the route for a battered spouse or child.
The Supreme Court has twice defined what counts as the notice that stops the clock. In Pereira v. Sessions it held that a notice to appear that omits the time and place of the hearing is not a notice under section 239(a) and does not trigger the stop-time rule. In Niz-Chavez v. Garland it held that the government cannot cure the omission with a later hearing notice: the stop-time rule requires a single document containing all the required information. Many people charged in the years before those decisions received a notice without a hearing date, and for them the clock may have run on well past the day they were served.
Section 240A(e) limits the number of grants: the Attorney General may not cancel removal and adjust status under the section for more than 4,000 people in a fiscal year. The regulation says that when no grant is available in the fiscal year, a judge who would grant a non-permanent resident's case must reserve the decision until a grant becomes available in a later year, so an approved case can wait after the hearing. Permanent resident cancellation involves no adjustment of status and is not held for a number.
The Application and the Hearing
The application is Form EOIR-42B for a person without a green card, or Form EOIR-42A for a permanent resident, filed with the immigration court. The applicant bears the burden of proving eligibility and that relief is warranted in the judge's discretion. The fee and the biometrics fee are paid through EOIR's payment portal before the application is filed with the court, unless a fee waiver is requested, and the receipt goes in the record.
| Item | As the fee page read on the review date |
|---|---|
| Form EOIR-42B, cancellation for a non-permanent resident | $1,690, plus $30 a person for biometrics |
| Form EOIR-42A, cancellation for a permanent resident | $730, plus $30 a person for biometrics |
| An appeal to the Board of Immigration Appeals after a denial (Form EOIR-26) | $1,060 |
- At the master calendar hearing the charges are answered and the judge sets a deadline for the application and a date for the individual hearing.
- The application is filed with the supporting evidence: proof of presence for every year (tax returns, leases, school and medical records, pay stubs, affidavits), proof of good moral character (police clearances, court dispositions, letters), the family members' citizenship or residence, and the hardship evidence.
- At the individual hearing the applicant and witnesses testify, the government attorney cross-examines, and the judge decides, orally or in writing, or reserves the decision for a cap number.
- A grant ends the proceedings; for a non-permanent resident the judge's order makes the person a lawful permanent resident as of the date of the cancellation, and USCIS issues the card. A denial can be appealed to the Board of Immigration Appeals within 30 calendar days.
Cancellation under the permanent resident route or the ten-year route can be granted once. The statute bars a person who has already received cancellation of removal, suspension of deportation or relief under former section 212(c) from receiving it again, and it bars certain others: J-1 exchange visitors who came for graduate medical education, other J-1 visitors who have not met or been excused from the two-year home residence requirement, crewmen, people who persecuted others, and people removable on security grounds. A prior grant, or a prior application denied on the merits, changes the strategy.
The Evidence Checklist
- Presence, year by year, for the whole period: tax transcripts, leases and utility bills, employment records, school and medical records, church and community letters, and travel records showing every departure and return.
- The notice to appear and every hearing notice, to apply the stop-time rule as the Supreme Court has defined it.
- Certified dispositions of every arrest or charge, in any state, and the statute under which each conviction was entered.
- The qualifying relatives' birth certificates, naturalization certificates or green cards.
- Medical, psychological and school records for each relative whose hardship is claimed, with letters from the treating professionals.
- Financial records showing the family's income, debts and dependence on the applicant.
- Country conditions evidence on medical care, schooling, safety and employment in the country of removal, as they would affect these relatives.
- Letters and testimony from employers, clergy, teachers and neighbors on character and ties.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Can I apply for cancellation of removal if I am not in immigration court?
- No. Cancellation of removal is granted only by an immigration judge in removal proceedings, after the charging document has been filed with the court. A person who is not in proceedings cannot file for it, and no rule entitles a person to be placed in proceedings in order to apply.
- Does hardship to me count?
- Not under the ten-year route. Section 240A(b)(1) requires exceptional and extremely unusual hardship to a spouse, parent or child who is a U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident. The applicant's own hardship is relevant only as it affects those relatives. The route for a battered spouse or child, section 240A(b)(2), does consider hardship to the applicant.
- My notice to appear had no hearing date. Does that help me?
- It can. The Supreme Court held in Pereira and Niz-Chavez that a notice to appear without the time and place of the hearing does not stop the clock on continuous presence, and that a later hearing notice does not cure it. If you reached ten years of presence after such a notice was served and before a complete one, the presence requirement may be met.
- What is the cap, and how long is the wait?
- The statute limits grants of cancellation with adjustment of status to 4,000 in a fiscal year. When the number for the year is exhausted, the regulation requires a judge who would grant the case to reserve the decision until a grant becomes available in a later year, which can take a long time. The wait does not apply to permanent resident cancellation.
- What if I have a conviction?
- It depends on the offense. A conviction under section 212(a)(2), 237(a)(2) or 237(a)(3) bars the ten-year route, with a narrow waiver for certain domestic violence offenses, and an aggravated felony bars the permanent resident route. Many offenses fall outside those sections, and whether a particular state conviction falls inside is decided by comparing its elements with the federal definition. Certified court records of every case are the first thing to gather.
- What happens if the judge grants cancellation?
- The removal proceedings end. A person without a green card becomes a lawful permanent resident by the judge's order, and USCIS issues the card. A permanent resident keeps the green card. The relief can be granted only once under the permanent resident route or the ten-year route.
Working With Our Firm
Harry Asatrian has represented clients in removal proceedings before immigration courts in New Jersey and New York, before the Board of Immigration Appeals, and in federal court petitions for review. A removal case begins with a review of the charging document, the immigration history and the family and work record, and a plain answer about which forms of relief are open.
Call (973) 735-2716 or use the contact form. Our office is at 72 South Maple Avenue, 1st Floor, Ridgewood, NJ 07450. Start with the removal defense overview for the other forms of relief and the appeals.
Attorney Advertising. Nothing on this page is legal advice for your situation, and reading it does not make you a client of the firm. Results depend on the facts of each case, and prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Government fees, forms and visa dates change; the figures here are a dated snapshot with links to the official sources.
Official Sources
Every statement of law, fee, form or timing on this page was read from one of these sources on the date shown. The law and the fees change; check the source before you rely on a figure.
- INA section 240A, 8 U.S.C. 1229b (cancellation of removal, the stop-time rule and the annual limit) (read 2026-11-05)
- 8 CFR 1240.20 (2025 edition), cancellation of removal and adjustment of status under section 240A of the Act (read 2026-11-05)
- INA section 101, 8 U.S.C. 1101 (definitions, including the O nonimmigrant and the U nonimmigrant at section 101(a)(15)) (read 2026-11-05)
- INA section 237(a)(2) and (a)(3), 8 U.S.C. 1227 (the criminal and document grounds of deportability that bar cancellation of removal) (read 2026-11-05)
- Matter of Monreal-Aguinaga, 23 I&N Dec. 56 (BIA 2001): exceptional and extremely unusual hardship (read 2026-11-05)
- Matter of Recinas, 23 I&N Dec. 467 (BIA 2002): the hardship standard met for a single mother of six (read 2026-11-05)
- Pereira v. Sessions, 585 U.S. 198 (2018): a notice to appear without the time and place of the hearing does not stop the clock (United States Reports, volume 585) (read 2026-11-05)
- Niz-Chavez v. Garland, 593 U.S. 155 (2021): the stop-time rule needs a single complete notice (read 2026-11-05)
- 8 CFR 1240.21(c) (2025 edition), the annual limitation on cancellation of removal: decisions reserved when no grant is available in the fiscal year (read 2026-11-05)
- Executive Office for Immigration Review, Form EOIR-42B, Application for Cancellation of Removal and Adjustment of Status for Certain Nonpermanent Residents (read 2026-11-05)
- Executive Office for Immigration Review, Form EOIR-42A, Application for Cancellation of Removal for Certain Permanent Residents (read 2026-11-05)
- 8 CFR 1240.8 (2025 edition), burdens of proof in removal proceedings (read 2026-11-05)
- Executive Office for Immigration Review, EOIR Forms (each form with its current fee: the EOIR-42A at $730 and the EOIR-42B at $1,690, each plus $30 a person for biometrics, as the page read on the review date) (read 2026-11-05)
- Executive Office for Immigration Review, Types of Appeals, Motions and Required Fees (appeals to the Board at $1,060, motions to reopen and reconsider before the immigration judge at $1,095, and the in absentia exception) (read 2026-11-05)
- Immigration Court Practice Manual, Chapter 4 (Hearings before Immigration Judges), section 4.15, Master Calendar Hearing, with 4.16, Individual Calendar Hearing, and 4.17, In Absentia Hearing (read 2026-11-05)
- 8 CFR 1003.38 (2025 edition), appeals from an immigration judge's decision to the Board within 30 calendar days (read 2026-11-05)
Facing a Hearing in Newark or Elizabeth?
Harry Asatrian will review your case and advise on every form of relief the facts support. Consultations are confidential.
Schedule a ConsultationOr call us directly: (973) 735-2716